|
A Review ofHabibi, You Are My WHAT?by Leyla Lanty
Summary
Overall Rating:
What Shira.net Users Think
The above poll includes responses submitted since October 12, 2009. Note: Shira has a policy against video producers asking their students, family, and friends to pad the votes, or campaigning for favorable votes through their web sites. Click here for detailed information about the policy.
Fact Sheet
* Pricing information was current as of the date indicated above, but may have changed since then. Please contact the video producer for the most current pricing information.
DescriptionThis DVD came about after Leyla Lanty developed a workshop titled "Habibi, You Are My WHAT?". When she announced on the Internet that she would be teaching one of these workshops, many people urged her to capture the workshop to video, enabling those who couldn't attend in person to still learn the material. Leyla engaged a videographer to tape one of her live workshops, which she then packaged for sale. That is how this DVD came to be. What It ContainsThe instruction is divided into these major sections:
Leyla uses a flip chart as a visual aid throughout. She had prepared it in advance with all her key points, and she references it every step of the way. The camera helpfully offers many lingering closeups of the pages, which I much appreciate. The instruction in the sections for "Habibi Ya Eini" and "Zay el Hawa" don't seem as strong to me as the section for "Nour el Ain". They still offer benefit, but the coverage of these two songs seems more superficial. I felt a bit torn in how to represent that in writing this review. If the instruction had stopped with "Nour el Ain" I probably would have highly praised how well Leyla analyzed the music and offered ideas on dancing to it, and to some extent the inclusion of the two additional songs weakened my overall response to this aspect of the video. Yet, the inclusion of the two additional songs strengthens the video as a whole by introducing additional vocabulary words and offering more practice in listening for familiar words in the lyrics. Also, by including them Leyla introduces two more songs that less experienced dancers may not know yet. So how do I criticize the less detailed presentation of these songs while at the same time saying I'm glad they're part of the video? I guess I just did.... It might have been nice if Leyla had included on the DVD some footage showing her performing to a portion of one of these songs, using the gestures taught. Such a performance could have illustrated the point she made verbally, that in an actual performance you would use the gestures sparingly to avoid looking cheesy. Still, the video is able to stand on its own without this. Although I normally dislike videos that are simply tapings of live workshops due to production quality issues, I feel that the use of the workshop format is a positive aspect of this video because it really brings out her personality. With real people to talk to, she's able to behave naturally and adjust the flow of her presentation according to the reactions she sees in them. The question-and-answer section at the end adds some information to the material presented on the DVD that otherwise might not have been mentioned. Through the use of microphone and intelligent camera placement, her videographer is able to avoid the usual production quality issues that arise with live workshops. The InstructorLeyla's on-screen demeanor is casual and pleasant. At the very beginning, she seems a bit nervous, but once she warms up to her subject she relaxes into it. It's apparent that she enjoys teaching this topic, and I feel she teaches it well. Her personality as she delivers the material is lively and holds my attention. The material is well organized. It is clear that Leyla has put a great deal of thought into choosing the topics to cover, organizing them into a logical flow, selecting relevant music to illustrate the vocabulary, and identifying gestures to use with the lyrics. There are many useful insights into Arab culture included in this video. Some of them are mentioned as spontaneous casual comments, while others are carefully planned into the instruction. Leyla has spent extensive time in Egypt, much more than I have, and her expertise shows as she teaches this workshop. A good instructor always has a deep level of knowledge beyond the material being taught in the class, and it's easy to see that Leyla has this depth. The HandoutThroughout the workshop, Leyla refers the students to a handout. For those of us participating via video, the "Extras" section describes how to obtain a copy. Hint: Internet access is needed, and a printer is recommended. The content-rich handout is 8 pages long. It contains everything from the flip charts, plus additional vocabulary words that are not discussed as part of the video. If you decide to purchase this video, I strongly recommend obtaining the handout before you begin working with it. The camera often shifts away from the flip charts to show Leyla's face, and when it does, it's helpful to have access to the version that appears on the handouts. On my first viewing of this DVD, I did not yet have the handout printed. I was able to follow the instruction without it, but after printing it and reviewing sections of the video I have found that the handout helps me greatly with following along and retaining the material. The handout identifies several commonly-occurring words in each song, enough to give you some ideas on where/how to gesture, but it does not contain complete translations of any of the songs. Production QualityDon't let the fact that this was taped in a live workshop make you hesitate to try this video. Although it's a low-budget production, the quality is perfectly acceptable. It's quite well lit, there is never a problem with other people being between Leyla and the camera, the camera always shows what it should, and Leyla uses a lapel microphone which leads to excellent sound quality. In fact, this live-workshop video is much better production quality than many videos I've seen filmed in people's dance studios. Although there's occasionally a moment of intrusive zooming or a blooper that could have been removed through editing, there are not many of these issues and they don't intrude on my abilty to enjoy the video. The Physical DVD ItselfAlthough Amazon says the DVD is Region 1, my testing shows that it will work in all regions. The DVD has been divided into 14 chapters, which are logically organized. The chapter breaks appear in sensible places. There is a Chapters menu with informative titles that make it easy to navigate through the video. It's easy to work with.
Is It Right for You?
You Will Probably Enjoy This Video If
This Video Probably Isn't Right for You If
What I Liked, What I Didn't
What I Liked:
What I Didn't Like:
In ConclusionMusical interpretation is a very important component of belly dancing (particularly of Egyptian or Lebanese style), and it can be a challenge for a dancer to work with songs sung in a language she does not speak herself. This video discusses a rarely-taught aspect of musical interpretation - that of using a well-placed gesture or two to highlight something in the lyrics. I think this video provides an excellent starting point in teaching this aspect of the dance. Leyla is knowledgeable both about the Arabic language and about cultural nurances such as gestures, and she brings that knowledge into this video. The instruction contained in this video is worthwhile for any performer of Oriental dance who uses Arabic music. Leyla teaches at a level that is non-intimidating to people who do not yet know anything about the Arabic language. I found much in the video that was new to me despite having worked my way through a 30-lesson audio CD course in Arabic. The terms that Leyla teaches, such as "soul", "heart", "love", and "darling", wouldn't typically appear on mainstream Arabic instructional materials for tourists or business people, but they are very common in songs. So, for dancers, Leyla's video serves as a valuable complement to such instructional courses. This video offers a large amount of instruction (over an hour), for a low, affordable price. I feel it offers excellent value for the money, and I recommend it to anyone who dances to Arabic music, works with Arab musicians, or plans to visit an Arabic-speaking country. Leyla put the words "Volume 1" as part of this video's title. I hope this means she'll be planning a Volume 2!
DisclosureI have known Leyla Lanty since I was a belly dance student in the mid-1980's, back when she was friends with one of my teachers. Over the years I have come to be friends with her myself, and we have spent many hours doing things together in Egypt when our schedules led us to both be there at the same time. For many years, I have considered her to be one of my go-to people when I have questions about Egypt, its culture, and its dance scene.
Where to Get ItVia Amazon Stores
Via FilmBabyhttp://www.filmbaby.com/films/4368
Contact InformationWeb Site: www.leylalanty.com
|
| Contact Shira | Mailing List | Links | Search this Site | |